The tribunal finds it has no jurisdiction over the claims
China Heilongjiang International Economic & Technical Cooperative Corp. et al. v. Mongolia (Tumurtei deposit)Tumurtei cases involving Li Xiaoming
Three Chinese companies (China Heilongjiang, Beijing Shougang and Qinhuangdaoshi Qinlong) brought an arbitration against Mongolia, claiming that the licence for the Tumurtei iron ore deposit had been expropriated. The award describes Li Xiaoming as chairman of Tumurtei Khuder LLC and majority shareholder of Qinlong, one of the claimants; he gave witness statements for them. The four decisions below follow the case from the award to the US Supreme Court.
- 1/42017.06.30 · Permanent Court of ArbitrationPCA 2010-20In forceJudgment
- 2/42019.11.19 · United States District Court for the Southern District of New York
Motion to vacate denied; the award is confirmed
Beijing Shougang Mining Investment Co. et al. v. Mongolia: opinion and order confirming the award17 Civ. 7436 (ER)In forceJudgment - 3/42021.08.26 · United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
The district court's decision is affirmed
Beijing Shougang Mining Investment Co. et al. v. Mongolia: Second Circuit opinion19-4191In forceAppeal decision - 4/42022.06.27 · Supreme Court of the United States
The US Supreme Court declines to hear the case
Beijing Shougang Mining Investment Co. et al. v. Mongolia: certiorari denied (order list, page 9)21-1244In forceRuling
Related case
Criminal case, ruling
Under appeal171/2016/0175/Э2016.11.07 · 20 p.
Darkhan-Uul Inter-Soum Court of First Instance (Criminal Cases)
Darkhan Metallurgical Plant, Ministry of Finance of Mongolia, L. Bayartsogt +5