UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
BEIJING SHOUGANG MINING INVESTMENT
COMPANY LTD., CHINA HEILONGJIANG
INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC & TECHNICAL
COOPERATIVE CORP., and QINHUANGDAOSHI
QINLONG INTERNATIONAL INDUSTRIAL CO.
LTD, OPINION & ORDER
17 Civ. 7436 (ER)Petitioners,
– against –
MONGOLIA,
Respondent.
Ramos, D.J.:
For over a decade, the petitioners, a group of three Chinese companies, and respondent, the country of Mongolia, fought over the ownership of a valuable mining concession. �ose proceedings started in the Mongolian court system, rose to its Supreme Court, jumped to an arbitration tribunal in New York, and, pause for now here, in the Southern District of New York. �e Chinese companies move this Court to perform a de novo review of the arbitral tribunal’s decision that the dispute between the parties was not arbitrable, vacate that decision, and compel the parties to return to arbitration for a decision on the merits. Mongolia cross-moves the Court to defer to the arbitrators’ reasoning and confirm their award.
�e Chinese companies, by initiating this arbitration, affirmatively arguing for the tribunal’s jurisdiction, and vigorously participating in the seven-year-long arbitration proceedings, have waived their opportunity to object now to the arbitrators’ ability to decide arbitrability. �e Court therefore finds that the parties clearly and unmistakably agreed to place the question of arbitrability before the tribunal, and the Court confirms the award after Beijing Shougang Mining Investment Company, Ltd. et al v. Mongolia Doc. 21 Dockets.Justia.com